
The tomato pasta worth the airfare
Three kinds of tomato, a whisper of anchovy and enough lemon to keep it honest.
At a Glance
Story
Do not be frightened of the two anchovy fillets, and whatever you do, do not leave them out. Cooked into the oil at the start they melt away to nothing and leave no fish behind, only a deep savoury hum, since anchovies are loaded with the same glutamates that make parmesan and ripe tomato taste of more. Nobody will ever find them. Everybody will ask what you did.
Ingredients
- 3 tbsp olive oil
- 2 stems fresh basillarge
- 3 cloves garlic
- 1 Calabrian chilichopped (or to taste)
- 2 anchovy fillets
- 1 tbsp tomato pasteideally Sicilian estratto
- 2 vine-ripened tomatoeschopped
- 1 large heirloom tomatochopped
- 15 cherry tomatoes
- flaky salt
- 1 lemonzest and juice
- ½ cup Pecorino Romanograted
- ½ cup Parmigiano Reggianograted
- 16 oz pici or spaghetti
Method
This is the tomato pasta they serve you in Italy and then refuse to explain. There is no great secret beyond good tomatoes, three sorts of them, and the nerve to melt an anchovy where no one can see it. Pici, if you can find it, is the fat hand-rolled Tuscan noodle that drinks up sauce like this. Spaghetti will not sulk if you cannot.
- Warm the olive oil over medium heat and add the basil, garlic, Calabrian chili and the anchovies. Cook for about 5 minutes, pressing the anchovies with your spoon until they dissolve into the oil entirely.
- Stir in the tomato paste and let it cook for a minute, going a shade darker and sweeter. Add all three tomatoes and a good pinch of salt, cover the pan and cook for about 20 minutes, until the tomatoes have collapsed and gone soft.
- Off the heat, fish out the basil stems and the garlic cloves, then blend the sauce smooth in a blender. Return it to the pan, stir in the lemon juice and zest, and off the heat again fold in both cheeses so they melt rather than seize.
- Cook the pasta in water salted like the sea until just short of al dente. Lift it straight into the sauce with tongs, carrying a little of its cloudy water with it, and finish it in the pan. That starchy splash is what Italians call the mantecatura, the emulsifying that binds sauce to noodle so it clings rather than slides.
- Plate up and finish each bowl with a little more grated lemon zest. That last flash of zest over the top is what keeps a rich tomato sauce from tasting heavy, the oils in the peel read as brightness to the tongue.
More to cook

A lasagna with a short fuse
The golden lasagna's wilder sister, all smoky sausage and charred poblano with a chipotle streak, cooled by a lime drizzle.

Golden lasagna
A carrot lasagna so light you could eat the lot and still fancy pudding.

Spatchcock chicken over leeks and greedy bread
One bird on a bed of leeks, and torn baguette underneath drinking up every drop.

Bagna cauda for the anchovy-shy
The warm garlic and anchovy bath that quietly wins every party. Melting, not fishy, and gone before the coats are off.

Chunky chimichurri for steak night
Parsley, oregano, garlic and vinegar, chopped not blended. The steak's best friend.

Five-minute harissa yogurt
Smoky, cooling and quick. The yogurt does the calming, the harissa does the talking.

One-pot Pugliese sausage and potatoes
Peasant food that minds itself in the oven, as happy on a Tuesday as it is at a three-hour lunch.

Salsa cruda for peak tomatoes
Grated ripe tomato, garlic and basil. The less you do to it, the better it is.

Salsa verde, anchovy and all
Sharp, briny and green. The Italian one, not the tomatillo one.

Grated tomato and Calabrian chili
Grated tomato with a Calabrian kick and a lemon lift. Sauce or dip, your call.

Za'atar yogurt with sumac
Herby, tangy and green-flecked. The cooling spoon for anything off the grill.

Zhoug with a proper temper
The Yemeni green sauce that bites back. The cardamom is the tell.

Lemon pesto spaghetti, all zest and no juice
The Amalfi trick: zest steeped into the pasta water and pounded into the pesto, toasted almonds underneath, not a drop of juice anywhere.

Shrimp in a fish sauce caramel
Sugar taken to the edge of burnt, then doused with fish sauce: Vietnam's sweet-and-savoury backbone, wrapped around shrimp over jasmine rice.

Sweet corn campanelle with miso butter
Corn three ways in one pot, then the fix the original never knew it needed: white miso in the butter and a lemon squeezed over the lot.